Compare GEICO vs American Family Insurance BETA

See how working at GEICO vs. American Family Insurance compares on a variety of workplace factors. By comparing employers on employee ratings, salaries, reviews, pros/cons, job openings and more, you'll feel one step ahead of the rest. All salaries and reviews are posted by employees working at GEICO vs. American Family Insurance. Learn more about each company and apply to jobs near you.
GEICO company icon

GEICO

Employee Ratings

  • GEICO scored higher in 4 areas: Career Opportunities, Senior Management, CEO Approval and Positive Business Outlook.
  • American Family Insurance scored higher in 4 areas: Overall Rating, Work-life balance, Culture & Values and % Recommend to a friend.
  • Both tied in 1 area: Compensation & Benefits.
Overall Rating
(full-time and part-time employees only)
Overall Rating
(full-time and part-time employees only)
3.3
(based on 4266 reviews)
Overall Rating
(full-time and part-time employees only)
3.5
(based on 968 reviews)
Career Opportunities
Career Opportunities
3.5
GEICO employees rated their Career Opportunities 0.5 higher than American Family Insurance employees rated theirs.
Career Opportunities
3.0
Compensation & Benefits
Compensation & Benefits
3.8
Compensation & Benefits
3.8
Work-life balance
Work-life balance
3.0
Work-life balance
3.6
American Family Insurance employees rated their Work-life balance 0.6 higher than GEICO employees rated theirs.
Senior Management
Senior Management
3.0
GEICO employees rated their Senior Management 0.3 higher than American Family Insurance employees rated theirs.
Senior Management
2.7
Culture & Values
Culture & Values
3.2
Culture & Values
3.4
CEO Approval
CEO Approval
GEICO Ceo Todd Combs
94%
94%Todd Combs
GEICO employees rated their CEO Approval 21% higher than American Family Insurance employees rated theirs.
CEO Approval
American Family Insurance Ceo Jack Salzwedel
73%
73%Jack Salzwedel
% Recommend to a friend
% Recommend to a friend
56%
% Recommend to a friend
66%
American Family Insurance employees rated their % Recommend to a friend 10% higher than GEICO employees rated theirs.
Positive Business Outlook
Positive Business Outlook
56%
GEICO employees rated their Positive Business Outlook 10% higher than American Family Insurance employees rated theirs.
Positive Business Outlook
47%

Salaries

Salaries for similar jobs
Salaries for similar jobs
Substitute Teacher1 Salaries
£34,000/yr
Project Manager1 Salaries
£28,400/yr
Assistant Store Manager1 Salaries
£28,208/yr
There are no salaries matching this company.

What Employees Say

  • GEICO had 392 more reviews than American Family Insurance that mentioned "Great benefits" as a Pro.
  • "Work life balance" was the most mentioned Con at GEICO.
  • "Upper management" was the most mentioned Con at American Family Insurance.
Pros
Pros
"Profit sharing"(in 747 reviews)
"Great benefits"(in 446 reviews)
Pros
"Work life balance"(in 56 reviews)
"Great benefits"(in 54 reviews)
Cons
Cons
"Work life balance"(in 213 reviews)
"Call center"(in 193 reviews)
Cons
"Upper management"(in 36 reviews)
"No benefits"(in 32 reviews)
Featured Review
"cash"12 Jan 2020

Current Intern - Cashier

I have been working at GEICO for more than 8 years

Pros

great customer service on the till

Cons

not a lot of friendky people

Advice to Management

don't work

Current Employee - Director

I have been working at American Family Insurance full-time for more than 5 years

Pros

Commitment to employees, communities, and customers. Very flexible and family-focused, fantastic benefits. Transformation to being agile and innovative.

Cons

Some legacy mindsets being overcome, which come along with any company of similar age

Job Postings

American Family Insurance has 85 more recently posted open jobs than GEICO.