Poorly run sales department;little commission;high turnover - Vehicle Protection Specialist CARCHEX Employee Review

2.0
24 Sept 2019
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

The people are nice. Most of the managers are really nice and helpful, albeit a little disconnected with the voice of the customer.

Cons

The product is absurdly overpriced and you barely get any money for selling it. You have to discount it to stand a chance at even selling it. And good reps are quitting. They tell you in training "stick to the script and you'll make $5K-$10K a month easy". Nobody makes even close to that, not even tenured reps. That went out the window a year ago. Now you have to sell 45 policies a month just to make a measly $2K-$3K commission and you have to work lots of overtime to do it. And if you work overtime and don't end up hitting bonus it equates to about $5/hr. How is that even legal?!

avatar
CARCHEX Response
6y
Thank you for sharing your experience as a Vehicle Protection Plan Specialist at CARCHEX. Feedback from current and former employees help us get even better. We are confused about your comments because as a frequent winner of Selling Power’s “50 Best Companies to Sell for Award”, our employees have communicated quite the opposite. In addition, the facts also refute what you are claiming. We pride ourselves in our ability to quickly and effectively train new Vehicle Protection Specialists, so they can hit our sales floor and begin making the amount of money you mention in your review. Most new Vehicle Protection Specialists are making $5,000 a month by the end of their 3rd month of employment and that is just the beginning. On average, Vehicle Protection Specialists who have been employed for one year or more earn $85,000 per year (many make much more than this). Just looking at our September earnings alone, over 52% of our Vehicle Protection Specialists earned more than $5,000 in September, with over 33% of them earning in excess of $7,500 in September. A very attractive benefit of becoming a Vehicle Protection Specialist at CARCHEX, is there is NO COLD CALLING. In exchange for providing hot leads for our entire Vehicle Protection Specialist team, we do have to set economically feasible sales goals that are consistent with the investment we make in leads. You are correct that as we expanded our marketing (resulting in more leads) and enhanced our sales process with additional support staff (resulting in Vehicle Protection Specialists being able to spend more time selling and less time dialing), the goals have increased and the earning associated with achieving lower sales volume has been adjusted appropriately. However, those Vehicle Protection Specialists who follow our proven sales training, easily achieve unit sales that earns them in excess of $5,000 per month. It is clear from your comments that you don’t understand how overtime is calculated and paid. Overtime pay for commissioned sales professionals is complicated and not so easy to understand. We appreciate that feedback because it tells us that we are not doing a sufficient job in educating our Vehicle Protection Specialist Team on how overtime is calculated and paid. We will change that immediately. Interestingly enough, most of the top earners mentioned above work little or no overtime in order to achieve their high earnings. Overtime is not required and purely voluntary. It is most commonly used when a Vehicle Protection Specialist is trying to reach a unit bonus that is within one or two units. Not only does that Specialist achieve the desired unit bonus, they also get paid overtime based on their entire monthly commissions! Finally, you take issue with our pricing strategy. We make it clear from the first day we meet potential Vehicle Protection Specialists in the initial interview that our business model is not based on having the lowest price but rather providing the customer with the HIGHEST level of protection for the most competitive price. We truly care about our customers and strive to provide the best value for their needs, which does not always translate into the lowest price. From your comment, it sounds like we also need to beef up our training regarding our pricing strategy. Thank you for taking the time to provide this review. As you can tell, we have learned some things from your review and plan to take immediate action to improve.

Explore other reviews about CARCHEX

5.0
11 Nov 2025
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Fun work environment. Fast paced. Lot to do.

Cons

None I personally can speak on.

3.0
7 Oct 2025
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

You make a lot of money especially when I was there That’s about it

Cons

Pressure sales tactic No opportunity for growth Literally carshield too Lie to customers

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All