Member Advocate - Member Advocate Collective Health Employee Review

2.0
1 Mar 2018
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

The perks are really really great. I'm talking outstanding health, dental, and vision insurance. Free lunch M-Thurs is great. There's activities like yoga, soccer, volleyball. The culture is great and it's fun for those who like free stuff.

Cons

For the Member Advocate role specifically there is something important to know. It's customer service and it's a call center. It's a glorified call center with great perks but you are on the phone saying "Thank you for calling, how can I help you?" for 7 hours straight. When people call regarding their insurance they are not in a great mood so this role is emotionally exhausting and extremely mundane and repetitive. The idea is to hire students from top schools and then keep then in a stagnant role for 1-2 years.. That's just an unrealistic hiring model. There's no room for growth and learning plateaus quickly. Management is a few years out of school so there is no mentorship or guidance, just a Team Lead clique. Your career opportunities are subpar. Enjoy the perks but don't expect to be challenged or supported in this role.

avatar
Collective Health Response
8y
I’m Roy Gilbert, and I am the COO of Collective Health. I read your review and I am sorry to hear that you had a poor experience as a Member Advocate. Our MA’s are core to our mission of providing an amazing member experience so people can understand and take control of their healthcare. We take exceptional care in hiring, training, and mentoring our team. We are happy that even though this is a challenging role, we hire less that 5% of the people who apply and over 90% of our candidates accept an offer to join our program. Your feedback is appreciated and helpful, and matches up with some of the things we are improving (for example, our new scheduling tool offers a lot more flexibility than the home-grown solution that you had to use). I would like to address a few things called out here: - As an MA, you get the opportunity to work with a manager who is passionate, caring and works hard to mentor you and their high-performing team. Manager roles on our team are reserved for people who excel in the core job -- we believe that the best leaders are those that have demonstrated the intricate knowledge needed to excel in a role. All of our new managers receive extensive training, and they work extremely hard to support their teams. - We structure our Ops team differently than the way a call center would, which is why you probably heard us say, “We aren’t a call center!” over and over. Our jobs require us to solve complex problems with our customers that directly impact their health and their finances, and there is often no script to follow. These problems require horsepower and empathy. That’s why we hire people with critical problem solving skills, enthusiasm for digging into systemic issues, and a tolerance for ambiguity. Our training program is demanding and our MA’s that succeed in the program learn the details of our complex healthcare system in a way that no graduate course can duplicate. - The MA role is in many ways the first step to an amazing career within a fast-growing startup. Our entire Ops team is growing fast, and if you are a strong performer then after your first year there are opportunities across the team in specialist functions, client and partner management, and team leadership. And other high-performing members of the Ops teams have moved on to other Collective roles like product design, sales, etc. Since the organization is dynamic, it’s not a sharply defined career ladder but instead our best people are forging their own path in an exceptionally fast growing company. Thanks again for your feedback, and I sincerely hope you have success in whatever you do next. Roy Gilbert Chief Operating Office

Explore other reviews about Collective Health

5.0
5 Jun 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Great company so far i have seen

Cons

No cons so far i have seen

2.0
15 May 2026
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Good benefits, especially health insurance. Some very intelligent people. Company mission is great.

Cons

Untrustworthy leadership that makes reactive choices and publicly badmouths their subordinates to other subordinates. Politics are HUGE here. I have quite literally heard of leadership making decisions on firing people simply because they don't "like them". I genuinely didn't know people behaved like this outside of those outlandish tv shows and movies where people have no tact and are completely unprofessional. Yelling and pointing fingers is normal when it comes to escalated matters, and working over 40 hours is not only typical, but expected. Weekends are not off limits either, and we get fake commended for our hard work and dedication, when really we would have just been reprimanded if we protested on constantly working outside of the 9-5. I have witnessed employees crying from different departments and levels; managers too.

avatar
Collective Health Response
1w
Thank you for your feedback and for your years of dedication to our mission. While we are glad you valued our benefits and your talented colleagues, we are concerned to hear about your experience with leadership and the workplace culture. We strive to maintain a professional environment and take reports of unprofessional conduct or reactive decision-making very seriously. If you have additional feedback you would like to share, we welcome further conversation at letstalk@collectivehealth.com as we work to improve our employee experience.
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All