Believe the Negative Reviews – They Are All True - Finance McMaster-Carr Employee Review

1.0
26 Apr 2025
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Decent salary and benefits. You may meet some wonderful coworkers.

Cons

Before I started working here, I was skeptical about all the negative reviews. I thought, “It can’t be that bad.” But after working in the company’s finance department, I’ve seen everything firsthand, and I can say with confidence: every bad thing you’ve heard is true. Yes, they pay well and benefits are great. But the way they treat employees—especially individual contributors—is awful. We are not humans for them. The biggest issue? Your work is graded based on vague “principles” that management can twist however they want. You can bring in huge payments from customers, but if you don’t do it in the so-called “McMaster-Carr way,” your performance will be downgraded. Management claims that they know what customers will think and do after receiving our emails/calls. There is no objective way to succeed here. If you try to advocate for yourself or question how things are done, they will find a way to get rid of you. I saw many good people go because of that… Management is ruthless, with a massive ego but no real leadership or people skills. Supervisors will sit with you at lunch, smile at your face, and then the next day, you’re gone. HR is a joke. They’ll pretend to sympathize with you, but at the end of the day, they exist to protect management, not employees. The sad truth is that the skills you will develop here are not valuable or transferable in the real world. This company operates in its own bubble, and what you learn here doesn’t translate to other jobs. If you’re considering working here, think carefully. The money might be tempting, but the stress, toxic culture, and instability are not worth it. I regret accepting their offer, and I wouldn’t wish this experience on even my worst enemy. I am very happy that I finally left this terrible place!!

Explore other reviews about McMaster-Carr

5.0
14 Jun 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

At least in the Systems department, it’s a helpful and collaborative environment.

Cons

3 days in office and potentially long commute from the city

4.0
16 Jun 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

- Pay/benefits are incredibly generous - People are generally easy/nice to work with - Note that the Systems department seems to be fairly isolated from the negative issues discussed in other reviews (e.g. tension between warehouse workers and management) - I haven't experienced any of those issues within the systems department. In my opinion, Systems is a great place to work and develop as an engineer. - Hybrid work style (3 days in office). Personally, I like hybrid more than both fully in-office and fully remote styles. - Great cafeteria with good food and cheap prices. - Good work/life balance (outside of being on call, I can leave work at work).

Cons

- Work is not super interesting to me. I come from a highly technical, but very different (not ecommerce/industrial supplies), background where I was doing work I was much more interested in. No doubt there are folks in Systems who love the domain though. - While I'm not on call a ton (1-2 weeks every few months), I really hate being on call. I like to leave work at work. Note that joining at least one reliability team is expected within your first year or so.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All