Skip to contentSkip to footer
      employer cover photo
      employer logo
      employer logo

      Members 1st

      Engaged employer

      Members 1st reviews

      Terrible management - Anonymous employee Members 1st Employee Review

      1.0
      13 Feb 2024
      Anonymous employee
      Recommend
      CEO approval
      Business outlook

      Pros

      Pay was nice Benefits were okay

      Cons

      Management is the worst I’ve ever seen, specifically in lending. If you aren’t a family member of someone important or best friends with a manager you are nothing to them. They promote the wrong people. Management is gossipy and catty. No work life balance. They expect you to be a robot, not a human. If you aren’t willing to sell your soul this isn’t the job for you. If you’ve got friends in high places you can just make your own schedule, leave to go golfing if you want but if you don’t have friends in high places you can barely take a lunch break. Not allowed to have personal conversations with your team during work hours- it’s a cult. Don’t do it.

      Explore other reviews about Members 1st

      5.0
      12 Aug 2025
      Member service representative
      Recommend
      CEO approval
      Business outlook

      Pros

      Competitive salary with REAL opportunities to advance. Great benefits, matching 401k, excellent health insurance, tuition reimbursement Work with happy/positive people who love what they do Build relationships with the people from your community.. ,

      Cons

      Having to deny members from loans Pushing products and services to members randomly some “cold calling”

      avatar
      Members 1st Response
      5mo
      Thank you for sharing your experience. We’re thrilled to hear you’ve found competitive pay, great benefits, and opportunities for advancement, as well as a positive team environment and meaningful connections with our members. We appreciate your honesty regarding the challenges of denying loans and occasional product outreach. Feedback like this helps us continue refining processes to support both our associates and our members. If you’d like to share additional thoughts, we welcome your input anytime at 717-458-6934. Thank you for being part of our team and for helping us live our mission every day! The Members 1st Team
      3.0
      13 May 2026
      Business credit analyst
      Recommend
      CEO approval
      Business outlook

      Pros

      Flexible Schedule on the business team. 401(k) is amazing. Healthcare is great.

      Cons

      Poor leadership across the board starting with VPs. C-Suite claims to be transparent, but then people (VPs) who are friends with the CEO get hired out of the blue. Poor PTO plan. No cost of living adjustments on already poor salaries. Does not value tenured employees. Prefers to hire new, cheap labor instead of treating invaluable tenured employees with dignity and a fair pay.

      See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All
      Related searches: Members 1st jobs | Members 1st salaries | Members 1st benefits | Members 1st interviews
      Members 1st reviewsMembers 1st review