"Culture Fit" - Anonymous employee PLOS Employee Review

2.0
22 Sept 2018
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

I know what it's like to be frustrated trying to access scholarly articles and resources that are locked behind paywalls you can't afford. There is definitely a place for democratizing publishers like PLOS ONE, and, while there are finer points to be made about the pay-to-publish model, the overall mission is a worthwhile one. The workload for publication assistants in particular is overextending, but there is no expectation for you to work past your allotted hours for the day. The company fixes up weekly, in-house "happy hours," which are quite generous. There are some good opportunities for projects if you can manage the time for it.

Cons

Publications assistants on PLOS ONE really bust their chops and there is lots of turnover because it is just not sustainable. I just want to make an important note about how the company hires and promotes based primarily on "culture fit." This puts a premium on Western ideals like extraversion, culturally-insensitive ideas of good worker and leadership traits, and the unchecked personal discretion of managers and social cliques within the office. PLOS is a prime example of "culture fit" becoming discriminatory in nature. By now they are well-known for promoting pretty horribly, and you can read past reviews to get an idea of this. In this part of the country, no one is explicitly racist or even intends to be, but if your ability to mesh with predominantly white managers or social groups and exhibit Western-centric leadership traits is what gets you appreciated or promoted, then this kind of working climate, like so many, are simply favorable to those who are predisposed to it, as in highly favorable to white people cut from a certain cloth or background and those that 'hack' it. "Soft" racism if you will. Just read about all the literature that's come up about "culture fit" becoming another subtle form of racism and discrimination. It's a ceiling that exists for so many people of color, as well as those who don't readily fit the traits valued in individualistic, capitalist culture. There are many well-meaning people who, whether they know it or not, reinforce the status quo. PLOS company culture is a really good example of these things at play. I am grateful for the time I had here, even made some nice work buddies, but this point definitely needs to be made. In these times especially, there is no need to mince words when it comes to things like this. We should all be calling it out when we see it.

Explore other reviews about PLOS

5.0
26 Nov 2025
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Ambitious and idealistic, so plenty of opportunities to contribute creatively.

Cons

Ambitions are sometimes too high.

avatar
PLOS Response
5mo
Hello- thank you very much for taking the time to write your review. We read and appreciate each one. I think your comment on ambitions is very interesting and I'll be sharing with leadership. Take care!
4.0
23 Nov 2025
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Co-workers are great and hard working.

Cons

Opportunities for career advancement is limited on some teams.

avatar
PLOS Response
5mo
Thanks so much for your review. We appreciate your time and thoughtful feedback. We are currently working on career advancement initiatives and believe this should be a core focus as we go into 2026 and beyond.
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All