employer cover photo
employer logo
employer logo

Achievement First

Is this your company?

It's that time of year again, and they are short staffed. - Teacher Achievement First Employee Review

1.0
22 Aug 2016
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

The children are great. There are some nice coworkers. No one has died from overwork yet.

Cons

During the summer and early fall, without fail, there are a string of positive reviews for AF. This is because they are short staffed, and need to fill vacant positions. Quickly. This is for a few reasons, some folks do some summer soul searching and quit because they realize they can no longer continue to treat kids like convicts, while working themselves to exhaustion (80+ hour weeks are not unheard of. 70 is fairly common - does the salary still sound so good now?). Other folks, new to this charter chain, realize that after a month, that they aren't part of the "cool" clique, and are thus treated kind of crappily by some of the more established staff and management - deliberately left out of after work functions, in school conversations, and greeted with eye rolls or feigned uncomprehension at staff meetings (hint: if you are not an enthusiastic TFA'r, have previous education experience that espouses methods other than Doug Lemov's, you're not going to fit in). And finally some new teachers figure out after a month or two that AF is a bit of a scam. Your hours are much more than promised, the mistreatment of children is systemic, management are often not very good at their jobs, their is a cultish aspect with staff who are happy, dissenting opinions are not heard, those dissenting are subject to retaliation, that AF's model creates children who are not capable of independent thought or are angry because they can't escape this sham. Regarding race, there is so much tension because young white folks that have read a book or two, explain to kids and black staff how they feel, without understanding what the real issues are.

avatar
Achievement First Response
9y
Thank you for your feedback. We are committed to creating an environment where people grow and push each other, but one that is also inclusive and overwhelmingly supportive, so I was very sorry to read about your experience working at Achievement First. I had the privilege of leading an AF school for 7 years, and we relied heavily on dissenting voices and promoted debate and conflict to make the best decisions for our kids. Your descriptions are certainly not the environment we strive to create. And we know that you are not our only team member that feels critical voices are not encouraged. In an anonymous survey that every employee at AF fills out every year, we ask if they feel comfortable sharing their feedback about their school with their school leaders, and last year 13% of our staff said they did not feel comfortable, which may not seem like a big number, but that means there are well more than 100 people within our schools who don’t feel that they have the agency and voice that they should. We know we have work to do. I would benefit greatly from hearing more about your experience and how we could prevent other valuable team members from having a similar one. Please email me at the contact below so that I can better understand, and learn from your perspective. The charged language you used when describing our kids (e.g., that we treat them like “convicts”) greatly disheartened me. You shared your view that our students are not capable of independent thought, but we are beyond proud of AF scholars who were the first in the family to attend college and are currently excelling in some of the top-ranked universities in the country. Our students have spearheaded social justice campaigns and organized protests. They have won citywide chess and Latin competitions, and we’re proud of our championship quiz bowl teams. Though we certainly do not take all the credit; our kids are incredible thinkers. (Admittedly, we might be a little defensive about our kids) Lastly, in regards to your advice for management, I’d be remiss not to point out that several of our leaders do send their kids to AF schools, including our founder and co-CEO, Dacia Toll, pictured above. Both of her boys love attending their Achievement First school. Best, Tom Kaiser Chief Talent Officer, Achievement First Tomkaiser@achievementfirst.org

Explore other reviews about Achievement First

5.0
19 May 2025
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Easy work and good team work

Cons

Didn’t have anything wrong with my team

3.0
11 Jun 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Dedication to education, core values, commitment to DEI

Cons

Return to office policy, lack of transparency from leadership, lack of communication from leadership

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All