Kelly Scott Madison Reviews

2.8

32% would recommend to a friend

(88 total reviews)

Joni Williams

65% approve of CEO

34% positive business outlook

Kelly Scott Madison has an employee rating of 2.8 out of 5 stars, based on 88 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have an average working experience there. The Kelly Scott Madison employee rating is 25% below average for employers within the Media and communication industry (3.7 stars).

Reviews by job title

88 reviews
1.0
28 Jun 2018

Disappointed

Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

It's an agency, so of course it has free snacks and the occasional meal brought by a rep. Honestly, the only real pro that is of substance is the coworkers. Not the management who does not care about your future, but the people who you work next to doing the same job every day. The people I met and the friends that I made is really the only positive thing about KSM.

Cons

Where do I begin? Kelly Scott Madison and KSM South prides themselves on being forward-thinking agencies that focus on being great places for people to grow their careers in. Unfortunately, this agency has a huge problem in understanding how to function. As a wannabe agency who is stuck implementing outdated practices with poor management, this is absolutely no place to advance your career, hence why so many people are either gone or in the process of looking for another job of substance. Here are some of the main cons I encountered at KSM: 1. There is a huge disconnect from the leadership team and their employees. If the directors actually paid attention to their employees and the dynamic of the work environment, they would see just how unhappy people are with their job. In my years at the company, I saw so many great workers leave who had such great potential. If only they would have been taken seriously or given better opportunities, they might have been able to grow with the company instead of actively searching for literally any other opportunity. It blows my mind how the people who are managers at this company literally have no clue how to manage their employees. It's so confusing. 2. There is absolutely no integration at this company. As much as KSM tries to instill this belief in their core values, integration is and will always be a challenge for this company. Media planning, digital, promotions, and broadcast are all separated and rarely communicate with one another. This leads to obvious politics in the company on which department is more important and valued more to the agency as a whole, which is overall toxic to the company and its employees. Awkward coffee dates with leadership members who clearly do not want to participate is not integration. It is pathetic and sad. 3. No culture whatsoever. This company struggles so much with wanting to be a cool place to work for with a great culture. The directors and leaders think that adding a ping pong table to the office will create the camaraderie that other cool and better-run agencies have. With the workload, you get shamed if you ever actually play with these "incentives", making them more for the look of a fun agency than an actual place to interact with your coworkers. When people get in trouble for trying to give the agency some personality, chances are "culture" should not be something highlighted by the company. Newsflash, making people feel terrible for wanting a break from looking at their screen all day will not help company morale. 4. Your input, concerns, and recommendations as an employee are unfortunately not taken seriously and will probably be used against you. I personally made legitimate concerns to our HR department and leadership team on ways we could work as an agency and was not taken seriously at all. The CEO of the company actually set up meetings with all the workers to discuss ways to better the company. However, don't give your true opinion on how to fix some internal issues because it just might be used against you in the future. 5. Goodbye to your social life! KSM does not care if you have a life outside of the office. The workloads that are on your desk (due to the many people that have quit) are enough to make you go insane. I can count multiple people who I have comforted in this office that physically cried at their desk because their workload was too much. I get agency life requires after hours, but staying until 9pm every day to meet a deadline that should not have been made in the first place is literally ridiculous. To be disrespected as an employee due to unrealistic expectations is insane. Overall, this agency has so many cons to it that future employees need to understand. When I had started, the agency was in a far better place than where it was when I left. Especially with KSM South being located in Austin, there is a huge disconnect from the Chicago location and the people who make the decisions that affect the entire company. The team put in charge in the Austin office unfortunately does not cultivate an exciting place to grow a long-term career, forcing great workers to leave and dump their work onto the remaining workers who already have one foot out the door. I'm disappointed with this agency and the lack of consideration it has for their employees on so many levels.

avatar
Kelly Scott Madison Response
7y
Hi there, I want to start by saying thank you for taking the time to provide this candid feedback and your time with KSM. As President, KSM’s advancement is my top priority—this includes our client solutions and impact, our agency structure, and, just as importantly, enabling our team members’ success. We hate to see anyone leave unhappy, so I take all feedback seriously and would like to provide additional context: You are right when you say that one of the best things about KSM is the value of our people. Our community is the heart and soul of the agency. Our talent is some of the best in our industry. Period. Working at a growing and changing agency is both a challenging and rewarding experience, we recognize that. All agencies, however, should strive to continually evolve. We know attracting and retaining great talent who thrives in change requires great support. Over the past year we renewed our emphasis on employee growth and wellness. This includes initiatives such as the launch and expansion of KSM Academy, health and wellness efforts, and our roadmap detailing structure and team integration. Our progress has not eclipsed our culture. Our “Be Bold” mantra hasn’t gone anywhere, but rather has evolved into enabling our community to be “Bold Builders”. We’re proud and excited about that. Our community is indeed changing, but remains strong. The best part of KSM culture has always been the connections between our people. We celebrate our wins together and help each other through change and a competitive, fast-paced marketplace. That’s what we hope our employees get out of KSM culture: a sense of community and an opportunity to be a “Bold Builder” As you mentioned, I regularly seek out our employees’ perspectives—two-way, open communication is critical. This is still true in your case; if of interest, I would be happy to discuss these concerns with you further. Regardless, I wish you the best in all your endeavors. Joni Williams
2.0
1 Nov 2023

Started out great, but declined very quickly

Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Lower level management is amazing. Incredible people to work with who do genuinely care about not only your career but you as a person. They’re the only reason I give KSM 2 stars. Unlimited PTO is a perk, but it is hard to take off without harming your coworkers and giving them more work to cover your absence. When I started, I loved KSM. It was a really great place to work for a while, that valued helping their employees grow. Upper management was always accessible and kind.

Cons

Incredibly low pay, constant layoffs (negative company growth), zero bonuses, insane long hours. I didn’t know a single person at KSM that wasn’t working 12+ hour days, and yet they still laid off nearly half the employees. Ever since the change in leadership, KSM has only lost clients, and can’t seem to close on any new business. Upper management now blames the rest of the workers for their mistakes and shortfalls, leading to lower level employees being terrified to talk to their directors about issues. 2023 has just been cataclysmicly bad for KSM and I don’t see how it’ll get better.

2.0
8 Jan 2024

What Happened?

Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

- Health insurance was phenomenal - Flex PTO was truly flex, unsure if that’s the case anymore after they laid off a lot of people in 2023 - A lot of great talent

Cons

- Burnt myself to the ground working here just to be let go on Zoom - Unrealistic expectations pitched to clients from leadership and lower level employees left to deal with the fallout - Was once remote encouraged and now seems to only favor employees in the Chicago market even if they aren’t top performers

Viewing 1 - 3 of 88 Reviews

Glassdoor has 94 Kelly Scott Madison reviews submitted anonymously by Kelly Scott Madison employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if Kelly Scott Madison is right for you.