Neill Reviews

3.5

62% would recommend to a friend

(78 total reviews)

Edwin H Neill II

77% approve of CEO

66% positive business outlook

Neill has an employee rating of 3.5 out of 5 stars, based on 78 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a good working experience there. The Neill employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Retail and wholesale industry (3.5 stars).

Reviews by job title

78 reviews
2.0
28 Oct 2014

Too Reactionary, too focused on outward image and sugarcoating

Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Fantastic people in lower ranks of the company. Educational opportunities (see cons though). Flexible schedules. Decent pay for the area.

Cons

Every department in the company is understaffed, creating unrealistic workloads on all employees. Current amount of staff reportedly is all they have a budget for and will not listen to employee's demands for additional staff. Regular and sudden lay-offs under the guise of 'cutting costs'. Layoffs seem to happen immediately before or after MAJOR investments into remodeling on or off campus. There is no job security in any department or in any division, despite what is said during company gatherings. No bonus structure for salaried employees outside of sales departments. Vacation time is given to you at the beginning of the fiscal year, and it is a set amount based on your employment length. There is no way to earn additional time off based on your job performance. Constant shifting of fiscal year start dates. Yearly evaluation and review process is lengthy - if you get a raise, it will be several months after your evaluation is complete, with no back-pay. Evaluation procedure is the same blanket forms for all departments and was built around the salon division - neill employs a variety of positions not in any way related to salons. Entirely too much focus on 'company culture' and not enough on actual job performance. Neill works closely with Aveda, and instead of creating their own corporate identity would rather adopt Aveda's. Nepotism and back-scratching become obvious even after a short time of working there. Favorites are chosen quickly and advance through the company quickly - via newly created positions that did not exist previously. Educational opportunities exist but staff are so overworked that there is no time to utilize the tools provided. Career opportunities exist but only if you want to stay in the beauty industry. Their budgetary constraints have created stagnant positions in the company with no room for advancement - they have lost good employees to this and will continue to do so. Upper management preaches that work should not be your life, but there are still employees who work 12-14 hour days and nobody seems to care. Exceptional at sugar-coating situations to employees and customers. Promises are made in company gatherings that are never mentioned again. Major policy changes affecting pay, benefits, etc sometimes do not get announced. Terrible communication in all areas of the company. Extremely reactionary. Products are released at the demands of customers who threaten to defect to competing products. Until that point, problems are very often neglected or swept under the rug. The same can be said about employee relations. It takes the threat of leaving in order to get a decent raise. Projects and plans are put into motion because upper management becomes fascinated with something and wants it immediately. Company will flat out lie to you when salaries, back pay, anything financial is discussed, despite claiming to have adopted transparency. Raises are capped annually at 3% IF you receive a perfect score on your review. Management is instructed never to give anyone a perfect score. Amount of raise never balances out with annual health insurance premium increases, so we make less each year. You are expected to be at your station during natural disasters such as hurricanes or freezing precipitation conditions. People who actually show up during natural disasters are rewarded for coming in, whereas people who do not want to risk their lives or families to answer a phone for 8 hours are put on the short list and made to feel guilty for not appearing.

1.0
12 Mar 2022

One Word: Chaos

Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

There are some good people within the company trying to make a positive difference.

Cons

Unfortunately, downside is those good people are smothered by either incompetence or negligence, or both. Many in upper management don’t seem to understand what the point of their job is and would rather spend time sounding and looking important than actually doing anything constructive. They are desperate to make $ at any cost, including working their people facing employees into the ground. Communication is TERRIBLE. Major changes are made without prior announcement, and when employees complain they are gaslit into thinking it’s their fault for not being a “team player”. Any suggestions for improvement made by those on the floor are ignored. Turnover is high and there is a good reason for that. The benefits offered are terrible - half of your paycheck will go towards a super high health insurance premium, and The PTO benefits are sad.

2.0
2 Jul 2018
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

The people I worked with were amazing! They were super friendly and made the transition into a new job so much easier for me because of it.

Cons

You are OVERWORKED in the Financial Aid Department. You are the only person in charge of every aspect in financial aid— processing verifications, compliance, operations, scholarships/state grants, the list continues. YOU are the ONLY one responsible of a WHOLE department for ONE school. That means you get to play catch up anytime you miss a day or go on vacation :) You deal with prospects, transfers, current students and students about to graduate; you honestly deal with more students than anyone in the school. You will see that the higher ups will invest money into admissions, retail, and educators, but there are never any intentions to hire anyone in Financial Aid... this is honestly a stupid move on the company’s part considering that Admissions RELIES on FA to meet quotas, and Financial Aid guarantees the only thing this company cares about: money. The company is cheap, and they will overwork and underpay you for your work; in fact, you are only limited to 40 hrs a week since the company does not want to pay over time for your work.... you will be stuck between choosing to leave things a mess at 40 hours or continue to work OFF THE CLOCK to get whatever you want to get done; it’s completely unfair. Oh and good luck if you don’t have any background in Financial Aid since you are only given 3 official days of training (while Admissions Managers get two weeks of it), after that, you are thrown into this job and are to figure it all out on your own...

Viewing 1 - 3 of 78 Reviews

Glassdoor has 79 Neill reviews submitted anonymously by Neill employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if Neill is right for you.