Great People / Bad Company - Student Success Coach City Year Employee Review

2.0
16 Aug 2022
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

The people you immediately work with are fantastic. Whether they be your impact managers, coworkers, students, you are surrounded by many amazing people looking to make a different in the lives of students in need.

Cons

The pay is awful. 10.5 hours a day, with a few days of extra work at a rate that is laughably below minimum wage. The training for the job involves liberal identity politics and preaches inclusion yet uses exploitation and does not address any of the actual issues in our school system. The company would not exist without inequalities in our school system, and while their training encourage young people do attack and dismantle them, City Year is well aware that that would put them out of a job. A attempt to actually enact real change at a school will be met with so much push back from the higher levels. What is worse, is they will weaponize impact managers (who are usually ex-student success coaches, and not much older than the people they manage) to squelch any kind of real change that threatens the companies position. This can create animosity in the work place.

Explore other reviews about City Year

5.0
13 Apr 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Well-organized/structured Transportation, healthcare, and AmeriCorps benefits Lots of teambuilding

Cons

Long days Uniforms A lot of professional development

1.0
3 Feb 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

if you put up with a year of lies, burnout, empathy fatigue from working with kids you can’t save, below minimum wage, then you can get a lot of money at the end.

Cons

they use the fact that you care about these kids to get you to put up with any and everything. that 900 something dollar check is basically 10 dollars an hour while you have to be an english and math tutor to multiple students, emotionally support them. mind you majority of these kids are experiencing poverty, several grades behind their reading and math level, extremely syndications home lives. these kids go through more than the average adult and you didn’t sign up to be a therapist. they are vague during the interview about the task and what you’re actually doing for a reason. so many other task and responsibilities. mangement does not care about you at all. they won’t care if you get injured, they won’t try to defend you to outside sources. i won’t ever get over how my school had teachers telling them kids they would never amount to anything, wouldn’t graduate, got called slurs, yet we stayed there, basically had to “turn the other cheek” and “be the lights” in the school….. majority of the people you work with WILL QUIT because who would want to stay in an environment like this. but majority of the people that leave will be black. that’s very telling.

2
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All