Morningstar has a lot of problems. It's unclear if it's better or worse than Corporate America as a whole. - Director Morningstar Employee Review

2.0
5 Apr 2021
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Morningstar has gone heavy on intangible benefits. Our offices are modern, and they come with amenities like espresso machines, soda fountains, and weekly bagel days. The culture is primarily laid-back, with some managers and teams being the exception. Goals aren't set ambitiously, or you can game the metrics. It is also notoriously difficult to get fired or significantly demoted, particularly as you become better at your job and can do the same work level in a fraction of the standard time. I would also say that our company is generally ethical and cares about our customers. I don't believe we serve them well, but we avoid creating pressures to hurt them. One of our subsidiaries, Pitchbook, offers an excellent product and has tremendous leaders at the time of writing.

Cons

Unfortunately, Morningstar also comes with many cons. Our products are abysmal. Analyst teams across the company refuse to use them even though they are free. Product teams are run by people who know nothing about our clients, their needs, or what it means to work in the financial service industry. We have been riding the coattails of Morningstar's first-mover advantage in fund data for decades, but it won't last forever. After the better part of a decade, our management team finally realized that we couldn't build software ourselves. Numerous senior leaders tried and failed to re-launch our flagship software product with disastrous results. We have now embarked on an M&A buying spree under our visionless CFO, who is laser-focused on the bottom line instead of plotting our future. The unfortunate side-effect is that our relatively small, $1.3 billion in revenue business now straddles almost every imaginable part of the financial service space. Our "lean" (read, cheap) operating mentality means that capital investment is scarce, and a lot of our businesses and products are houses of cards. Lower pay makes up for the relatively strong list of intangible benefits. Every three years or so, management does the usual dog and pony show of paying expensive consultants to pay-benchmark us. They'll explain that soon you'll see your appropriate pay ranges, your managers will be made aware of gaps, and so on. For one - senior managers know if there are gaps, but they don't know how large they are, and second - the budget they receive for pay increases does not scale with the level of underpayment. Morningstar knows it is underpaying you; they won't fix the problem. Again, people who are 2-levels from the CEO do not have those pay ranges, and per HR, "they never will." It's okay to pay at the low end of the range, but it makes for another issue: Morningstar employees tend to be of lower-than-average quality. The good ones churn out for better offers, and those that remain are a mixed bag. Morningstar is a poor place for those who want to join a pool of ambitious people. As mentioned earlier, we are spread too thin across the industry, meaning you will never feel well equipped to do your job. Your tools will be a 3-year-old underpowered laptop and ancient monitors. If you work in research, you will likely be missing key subscriptions to do your job. Suppose you are lucky enough to get them. In that case, it will only be after begging and pleading through multiple levels of the management chain - up to the executive leadership team. Finally, you've found someone who might be able to spend a few thousand dollars. Last but not least, the favored few who flub major products often escape punishment. If you've been with the company long enough, you are nepotistically re-tooled for another chance at incompetence.

avatar
Morningstar Response
5y
Thanks for your feedback—while I don’t agree with parts of it, I know we can get better and I appreciate the time you took to share your thoughts here. I am sorry that you have not found good opportunities to contribute your ideas and energy toward building the future of Morningstar. As a tenured colleague, you have been with us through some of our ups and downs and through major shifts in our organization. I disagree that we are riding the coattails of our fund data business, and if anything, the way we have directed our investments over the past five years demonstrate our intent to evolve with investors’ portfolios. We are ambitious yet thoughtful about our approach. I hear you, though, that we can always sharpen our focus and continue building infrastructure that scales and modernizes our organizations. As I wrote in our shareholder letter, I’d be the first one to admit that we should have delivered more impact from our software investments. But we’ve doubled down on investing in the team and I’d reinforce that we have continued growing in that space at above market rates. We are also working hard to address our growing pains, invest in our people and ensure they have career opportunities to grow for the long run. With respect to compensation, it’s true we are evolving the total rewards space to create a sustainable and employee friendly approach to managing and understanding our pay programs globally. As we’ve shared internally with the release of recent bonus data, there is a strong correlation to outperformance and compensation growth. And our data shows that we are good at weeding out underperformers but in keeping with our culture, we try to provide folks with a good leaving experience rather than thumping our chests about weeding out underperformers. It’s a nuance, but how we treat folks is important to me personally. We’d appreciate an opportunity to work with you on any of your feedback, so please reach out to your manager, or feel free to drop me a note confidentially. I won’t take it personally, and I know you’re just trying to make us better. ~ Kunal

Explore other reviews about Morningstar

5.0
21 Apr 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Collaborative environment, learning mindset, great work life balance

Cons

Not a lot of exceptions for fully remote status

4.0
23 Jun 2026
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Great benefits (e.g. 6% of salary 401K matching program, 6-week sabbatical after working 4 years). Good opportunities to switch roles within company. Most employees are great to work with.

Cons

Slightly lower pay relative to other companies. Management might be on a course of changing strategies across orgs too quickly, resulting in too many things breaking and failed outcomes. Removed 3 days a week in-office policy, which may lead to missed talent acquisition opportunities.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All